[ contents ] Vol.1 No.1 pp.21-37

DNA Paternity Testing:
public perceptions and the influence of gender

Authors: Lyn Turney, Michael Gilding, Christine Critchley,
Penelope Shields, Lisa Bakacs and Kerrie-Anne Butler.

abstract

This article reports on the findings of the Swinburne National Technology and Society Monitor in relation to public perceptions of DNA paternity testing, with particular reference to the effects of gender. The Monitor included a large-scale random survey and focus groups. Taken together, the survey and focus groups suggest that most Australians are ‘comfortable’ with DNA paternity testing in a variety of contexts. At the same time, this comfort is qualified, conditional upon the knowledge of all parties. It is also tentative, heavily grounded in the media rather than real-life experience. The survey and focus groups suggest that most men and women do not hold different perceptions of DNA paternity testing. There are several important caveats though. First, the focus groups suggest that reliance upon the media as a source of information leads to a ‘gendered perception’ of DNA paternity testing in terms of ‘paternity fraud’ for both men and women. Second, the survey shows that women are significantly more likely to feel comfortable about DNA paternity testing where all parties have agreed to the test, consistent with a concern to establish paternal responsibility and child support. Finally, the focus groups suggest that having a personal stake in DNA paternity testing generates opinions that are polarised on the basis of gender. The gender dynamics of public perceptions on DNA paternity testing are likely to become more important as the tests become more widespread.

Key words: DNA paternity testing, public perceptions, gendering of technology, biotechnology, fathers’ rights movement.

Lyn Turney is a researcher in the Biotechnology and Society program of the Australian Centre for Emerging Technologies and Society (ACETS) at Swinburne University of Technology.

Michael Gilding is Associate Professor of Sociology and Director of the Australian Centre for Emerging Technologies and Society (ACETS) at Swinburne University of Technology.

Christine Critchley is a Lecturer in Psychology and Director of the Public Perceptions program for the Australian Centre for Emerging Technologies and Society (ACETS) at Swinburne University of Technology.

Penelope Shields is an Honours student in Sociology at Swinburne University of Technology. Her honours thesis addresses women's perceptions of DNA paternity testing.

Lisa Bakacs is an Honours student in Sociology at Swinburne University of Technology. Her honours thesis addresses men's perceptions of DNA paternity testing.

Kerrie-Anne Butler is an Honours student in Sociology at Swinburne University of Technology. Her honours thesis addresses disclosure of incidental paternity testing.

[ contents ]            [ download full article as PDF format ]